I recently listened to a large sampling of the albums on the well-known Rolling Stone’s 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list. When it was first published, a vocal minority of critics, especially younger ones skeptical of the 60s/70s bias evident in the selections, claimed that it did not adequately capture the truly influential music from the broad spectrum of popular music. Instead of picking apart other lists, I thought I would create my own. These are my criteria:
Third, I informally weighted the prospects by their popularity on previous lists. If an album is a regular on these lists, it had to be twice as good to make it on mine as a lesser-known album.
Fourth, I tried my best to avoid repeat artists. The only exceptions were albums that I simply could not fairly leave off the list.
25) Audioslave – Audioslave (2002). Shortly after the breakup of Rage Against the Machine, former Soundgarden singer Chris Cornell and the guitarist, bassist, and drummer from Rage formed what seemed like a side project, Audioslave. However, their debut album held the same explosive intensity that made Rage popular, along with intelligent lyrics and passionate vocals by Cornell.
24) Culture – Two Sevens Clash (1977) I’m not sure if this album is better than the more well-known Exodus by Bob Marley (the original holder of this spot), but it certainly is one of the best reggae albums ever made. A concept album centered around the idea that the world would end on 7/7/77, it remains the best showcase of this very talented band.
23) AFI – The Art of Drowning (2000). Before AFI became a darling goth rock band on a major label, they were another bunch of East Bay punks. Their final album on their original label, The Art of Drowning is a tightly produced showcase of the band’s brooding, introspective lyrics, and punishing sound. Rarely has such intensity been so well-documented.
22) Fugazi – The Argument (2001). Indie gods Fugazi have always made groundbreaking music that defies genre conventions. They released The Argument as their last album before going on indefinite hiatus. It is by far their most coherent and accessible work and if it turns out to be their final release, it was a fitting swan song.
21) Bad Religion – Suffer (1988). Southern California punk band Bad Religion crafted a masterpiece with their trademark hyper-literate lyrics and 80s hardcore sound. In later years, they never advanced beyond the formula they perfected on Suffer, and who could blame them; it has few equals.
20) Operation Ivy – Energy (1989) Like Minor Threat before them, East Bay ska punk legends Operation Ivy produced a scene-rattling new sound that led to too much success too fast for four young men. The band broke up after only two years, almost coincidental with the release of their debut LP, Energy. But their influence is still felt in contemporary music. Their groundbreaking style fused ska, 80s minimalist hardcore, and a positive attitude sorely lacking in the scene, and the country, at the time. Two of the members went on to form the hugely successful pop punk band Rancid, but they could never match the energy captured on Energy.
19) Frou Frou – Details (2003). Early in her career, Imogen Heap was a relatively unknown British singer-songwriter in the vein of Alanis Morissette. Her breathy voice was a standout on her inconsistent debut, i Megaphone (a clever anagram of her name). In 2001, she teamed up with writer and producer Guy Sigsworth to create an unique electro-pop album featuring her signature octave-leaping vocal style on top of lush melodies. The album was not a commercial success, but the inclusion of one of its tracks in Garden State made Frou Frou famous. Mishandling of the album by the record company had soured the chances of another album. Heap released a second solo album in 2005 and a third in 2009 but both fell far short of Details. Here’s hoping for a reunion.
18) Stiff Little Fingers – Inflammable Material (1979). This blistering debut album by Belfast punk rockers smartly walked a fine line by making an overtly political album that didn’t get dragged down by its message. True to punk’s early days, it wasn’t afraid to experiment, such as the finale “Closed Groove.”
17) Idlewild – 100 Broken Windows (2000). Idlewild began as a indie band from Edinburgh. Their debut, Hope is Important, showed a large punk influence. However, their follow up was a true pop gem that combined their ear for catchy hooks with Roddy Woomble’s distinctive voice.
16) Tool – Lateralus (2001). Early in their career, L.A. headbangers, Tool, hinted that they were smarter than their own genre. Their 79-minute magnum opus, Lateralus, proved this without a doubt. Full of challenging time signatures and lengthy running times, the album was the antithesis of its radio-friendly peers. Like a dark symphony, the theme builds to its peak in the unforgettable three song cycle Disposition / Reflection / Triad.
15) Bouncing Souls – How I Spent My Summer Vacation (2001). Jersey punk rockers The Bouncing Souls paid their dues for years before achieving success. As chronicled in the entertaining documentary Do You Remember? the band faced a tough choice in having to fire their best friend and drummer Shal Khichi. The band considered calling it quits but instead found a new drummer and learned how to be a band again and have fun. The result of this creative energy is their best album to date, featuring the band’s trademark anthemic singalongs with lyrics from the heart.
14) Minor Threat – Minor Threat (1981). Clocking in at just 9 minutes and 20 seconds, this debut EP from Washington, D.C. exploded onto the early 80s scene and cast an immense shadow over the next decade of underground music. Espousing a lifestyle of no alcohol and drugs with a conviction that could only come from nineteen-year-olds, Ian Mackaye and company changed music and youth culture forever and left a lasting manifesto.
12) Dinosaur Jr. – You’re Living All Over Me (1987). Tremendously influential to the later grunge era, Dinosaur Jr. juxtaposed a heavy, distorted guitar sound with accessible melodies and soft-edged vocals. Never achieving mainstream success, this remains their strongest release.
11) Le Tigre – Le Tigre (1999). Riot Grrl pioneer Kathleen Hannah of the groundbreaking Northwest punk band Bikini Kill teamed up with friends to create a vehicle for feminist performance art and music. The group recorded their brilliant self-titled debut in 1999, which featured catchy lo-fi electropunk and quirky humorous lyrics.
10) Yeah Yeah Yeahs – Fever to Tell (2003). Consisting only of guitar and drums behind the screechy vocals of Karen O, the band made the old new again with their catchy garage rock style. Two tracks in particular, Maps and Y Control, showed there was a lot of depth behind the seemingly spare formula and they remain artists to watch as their sound has matured on subsequent releases.
9) Weezer – Weezer (1994). There is not a wasted second on this wonderfully catchy debut from Southern California nerd rockers, Weezer, led by Rivers Cuomo. It was tempting to eliminate this from the list because of their inability to know when to quit (and subsequent release of two self-titled albums) but it’s both impossible to dislike this album and to discuss 90s music without referencing it in some way.
8) Shakira – ¿Dondé Están Los Ladrones? (1998). Forget the airbrushed blonde on 2001’s international megahit Laundry Service; Shakira’s second album cover features the singer/songwriter with her natural hair color and her hands covered in dirt. Building on the strengths of her quiet debut album, Shakira wrote an accessible pop album that touches on the personal and the political, belted out in her distinctive bleating voice. Diverse influences including Western rock music, Lebanese styles, as well as immersion in the cheerful pop of Latin America, combine in this ambitious work that breaks predictable boundaries. There’s a reason it still remains one of the top Spanish-language sellers in the U.S. In any language, Shakira rocks.
7) Pixies – Doolittle (1989). Like Dinosaur Jr., the Pixies were tremendously influential over the movement that would eventually be called alternative rock and grunge. Widely regarded as the band’s most consistent and accessible album, Doolittle becomes only more relevant as it ages. In 2009, for the 20th anniversary of its release, the Pixies went on a limited tour where they performed the album in its entirety.
6) Catch 22 – Keasbey Nights (1998) Suburban Jersey ska punks Catch 22 parleyed their demo Rules of the Game into a brilliant full length album that many consider the pinnacle of the genre. Written while the singer, Tomas Kalnoky, was still in high school, it is coming-of-age concept album with darker subject matter lurking behind its caffeinated horn melodies.
5) Radiohead – OK Computer (1997). Following the success of the straight ahead rock formula on The Bends, Radiohead showed a glimmer of the experimentation to come on the accessible and much-praised OK Computer. Repeat listenings to most of the songs is a necessity, since Radiohead pack about as much into each song as other artists, if their lucky, manage to fit into entire albums.
4) Smashing Pumpkins – Gish (1991). Before the runaway success, the breakups, the reformations, and all the other baggage that hounded the band, the Smashing Pumpkins were four unknown alternative rockers recording four-track demos in 1989. Their debut album was a minor hit and hinted at brilliance yet to come. It combined the indie influence of grunge with the production and expanse of stadium rock, a formula Corgan would perfect on the band’s follow-up. Oveshadowed by later albums, Gish remains an unpretentious powerhouse that remains some of the band’s best, and certainly most honest, work.
3) Radiohead – Kid A (2000) A critic once remarked that it’s hard to believe Kid A is from the same band that released OK Computer, let alone from the same planet. Rejecting the mega stardom and all the expectations of another hit following OK Computer, Radiohead reinvented themselves as soundscape sculptors with one of the most interesting (and disliked) albums of the era.
2) The Clash – London Calling (1979). This is the magnum opus from The Only Band That Mattered. Although they suffered from inconsistency, especially on their later releases, everything on London Calling is spot on and this double album remains in a league of its own.
1) Smashing Pumpkins – Siamese Dream (1993). Hailed as the next Nirvana, the Smashing Pumpkins had a enormous amount of pressure on them to deliver a hit with their second album. The process nearly destroyed the band with songwriter Billy Corgan suffering from a nervous breakdown and drummer Jimmy Chamberlin struggling with alcoholism. In spite of this, Siamese Dream exploded as a megahit on the early 90s alternative rock scene.
The album continued to expand their signature style of droning overdubbed guitars that, unlike most of their peers, was influenced more by shoegaze than punk. Above all, the tracks are expertly arranged. The album builds intensity during the opening five tracks, then mellows out with the radio hit Disarm. You can almost imagine flipping over the vinyl for Side B when this transition occurs, even though the format was dead by the time the band released any material. This alternating build-up and release of tension is evident both within and between songs, and was one of the things that made (the original) Smashing Pumpkins such a great band, and it is executed flawlessly on Siamese Dream.
Well, that’s that. Let me know what you think. In case you’re wondering, I started this list about two years ago in 2009. I made some minor changes, but resisted the temptation to change it to reflect my current listening habits. I am curious to see which of the albums I’m listening to today will end up on the next list…
P.S. If you want to know what I really listen to on a daily basis, check out my Last.fm profile at http://www.last.fm/user/disgruntledgoat